Christopher Moore Home Page

The bulletin board is currently closed to new posts. Instead, why not check out Chris' Twitter and Facebook pages? Forum Index -> The Blog

Why the Kindle isn't a complete P.O.S.

  Author    Thread This forum is locked: you cannot post, reply to, or edit topics. This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.
Site Admin

Joined: 02 Mar 2004
Posts: 3833
Location: People Republic of Northern California
Why the Kindle isn't a complete P.O.S.  Reply with quote  

Letís face it. Iím a gadget guy. I like shiny new machines, sometimes because they are shiny and new. I have an Iphone, an Xbox360, 2 Playstations, two Macs, five PCs (4 of which I built), 3 flat-screen TVs, 2 Tivos, 4 Ipods, 3 Digital SLRs, 4 digital point and shoot cameras -- well, you get the idea. I am not, by any stretch of the imagination, a luddite, or anti-technical. I am not averse to change, nor am I nostalgic for the ďold daysĒ that never really existed. Neither am I evangelical about technology Ė I donít have any unnatural affection for my Macs, and I donít have any built-in revulsion for my PCs, or vice-versa. I like stuff that works, and I get pissed off at stuff that doesnít. Okay. Just so weíre clear.

So, despite my misgivings about E-books, which Iíll go into in a whole different blog, I bought a Kindle from Amazon. My history with the electronic book reader is this: I tried to demo the Sony reader three different times in
various book stores and there was never one that worked long enough to actually tell what it was like. But it was obvious that electronic paper had some possibilities.

Then, about two months ago, Amazonís Kindle PR division contacted me and asked me to do a blog for them, which I linked to here. I started looking into the Kindle machine, reading reviews, asking friends, checking out the specs. After all, you couldnít sign on to Amazon without being hit in the face with another Kindle promotion, and I sign onto Amazon a lot. (Note ridiculously long gadget list above.) So, even through Amazon had sent Kindles to my friends Neil Gaiman and Daniel Handler for review, and not to me, and I had done a blog for them (for fucking nothing, despite the fact that I actually get paid to do this Ė a lot) I ordered a Kindle. And eight hours later (Iím not kidding, eight hours) they lowered the price by $50.

So, you know, good start. So, here are my observations. And yes, this does go on a bit.

First, the good:

Kindle delivers available books in about 60 seconds through a free cellular data network, anywhere in the country. Itís fast, thereís a pretty good selection, and the screen is easy to read, with scalable fonts. Itís light, and the battery supposedly lasts a pretty long time, as power is only required to turn/change a page, not show text (itís not back lit). They ship it with a very nice leather cover, that almost completely negates the size and weight advantage, but does protect the Kindle if itís strapped in, and you can surf the internet, search Amazon products, and subscribe to and read blogs, magazines, and newspapers that are available from Amazon. You can also mail Word or other text documents to yourself and for ten cents a piece, Amazon will convert them to Kindle format and send them to your Kindle. These are all cool things. With a cheap SD memory card, you could easily carry 200 books with you in this little machine, and it highlights, clips, makes notes and bookmarks text.

Which means that the Kindle is not a complete P.O.S. It is, however, at least in this generation, a partial P.O.S.

The Not So Good:
1. No place to hold it. Every place you grab it does something -- activates some function.

2. No page numbers. They have reference numbers, but not actually page numbers. There's no way to find something or tell someone else how to find it. If you change font size, the reference numbers change. So, for instance, you might say,
"Oh my God, there's the funniest line in that new Sedaris book!"
"Really, what page is it on?"
"Uh, 2023 of 4432 in the second biggest font."
"Oh, yeah, that means something to me."

3. There's no place to clip the light they sell you to clip on it, and without the light, it's dark. Of course you can clip it to the cover they sell you but...

4. It falls out of the cover. There's a tiny "ledge" that's supposed to keep the Kindle in place, but it doesn't work. Yes, I could put a piece of stick-on velcro on the back and solve this problem, but I just paid $400 for this thing, I shouldn't have to add velcro to make it functional.

5. It shuts down. I took it to Los Angeles for a weekend trip. I'd charged it before I left, and it's supposed to be good for 7000 "page turns" on a charge, but even with the wireless off, it just stuck on a page on the second day, so I had nothing to read. I've never had a real book, "lock up".

6. Reading on the screen is disorienting. I read a lot on a screen, more than I read on paper, but reading a novel on a screen is disorienting. The screen is still pretty small, and a full page of text from a book isn't displayed. You never have a feel of how far along you are in a book. You don't know how far from the end of the chapter you are. There is a little line of "progress dots" along the bottom of the page that's supposed to indicate how far along you are, but it doesn't feel "real". It think if you could make it default to page numbers that mirror the real book, and you knew you were on page 44 of 400, you'd have a better idea. The progress numbers aren't always right, either. I loaded the manuscript of my new book into it. The reference numbers keep showing things like, 2483 out of 98. Which, you know, is confusing.

So, the Kindle, in my opinion, just isn't quite there. And understand, I think there's a certain inevitability to electronic books, so this is not a rant against the form. For some things, particularly college courses, I think e-books could rock hard. But until there's a generation who has never read or worked with paper books, the "analog" aspect of the reader has to be a lot better. You've got to somehow simulate the good things about paper books (and I don't mean the smell or the fact that you can tear the pages out and wipe with them if you're stuck dropping dooky in the woods), while taking advantage of the assets of e-books.

I'll have a whole new blog on e-books soon, in which we'll explore how you can decorate your garage to accommodate your own homeless author guy, who just got Napstered out of a job.

Meanwhile, e-book owners, share your thoughts.


Post Sat Jun 14, 2008 11:44 am   View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
  Display posts from previous:      
This forum is locked: you cannot post, reply to, or edit topics. This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.

Jump to:  

Last Thread | Next Thread  >

Forum Rules:
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum

Templates created by Vereor and Ken